Cancelling DEI? Then Out With the NFL Draft
Do you believe that those who are struggling should be given intentional advantages to help them succeed?
What if those advantages are deliberately more favorable than what's offered to those already at the top? What if we created entire systems designed to give extra support, resources, and opportunities to those who are behind?
If you felt a visceral "no" just now, I get it. Such suggestions often trigger immediate pushback about merit, fairness, and earning your way.
But what if I told you that some of America's most beloved and profitable institutions have been doing exactly this for decades? And not only do we accept it - we enthusiastically tune in every week to watch it work?
Welcome to the NFL draft.
Every year, we watch a system that deliberately advantages struggling teams. The Browns don't get told to "pull themselves up by their bootstraps." The Giants aren’t accused of cheating when they get early picks of top talent. Instead, we've built entire structures to ensure that those at the bottom get extra help, additional resources, and preferential access to new opportunities.
And here's the kicker: Look at the Kansas City Chiefs heading into Super Bowl 2025 this Sunday. Despite a system that deliberately gives advantages to struggling teams, the Chiefs are appearing in their fourth Super Bowl in five years. Having systematically lower draft picks hasn't destroyed their ability to excel. They've simply had to continue working hard and making the most of their opportunities - just like everyone else.
Giving advantages to those who are behind doesn't automatically diminish those at the top. The Chiefs aren't losing because other teams get better draft picks. Excellence, merit, and hard work still matter – we've just created a system that gives everyone a better shot at achieving them.
Why? Because we understand something fundamental about sports that we seem to struggle with in other contexts: Sometimes, helping those who are behind lifts up the entire game.
Now, let's be clear - the challenges faced by struggling NFL teams aren't directly comparable to the systemic barriers and historical disadvantages faced by marginalized communities in our society. Professional sports franchises worth billions aren't the same as generations of families who've been denied access to education, housing, or career advancement opportunities. The parallel isn't perfect.
But the principle illuminates something important about how we think about advantage and opportunity. If we can understand that giving struggling teams extra support makes the whole league stronger, why do we resist programs designed to give historically disadvantaged groups better access to opportunity? If we celebrate systematic advantage every Sunday, why do we question it on Monday morning?
I don't claim to have the perfect policy solutions for addressing generations of systemic inequality. These are complex challenges that require thoughtful, nuanced approaches. But what I do know is this: There are people and communities who need us, as a society, to create better pathways to opportunity - not handouts, but real chances to compete and excel. Just as we've done in sports, we can create systems that both maintain high standards and ensure everyone has a fair shot at meeting them.
The timing couldn't be more relevant. As we debate dismantling DEI programs in 2025, millions will gather this Sunday to watch our most profitable sports league showcase a system built on the principle that those with the longest distance to cover need extra support to compete. So perhaps before we rush to declare victory over "unfair" corporate DEI initiatives, we should ask ourselves: If we can cheer for equity on the field, why not in the workplace?
You may also like
AUSTIN, Texas (November 20, 2024)—Aptive Index, a leader in psychometric assessment and behavioral insights, is thrilled to unveil the results of its most comprehensive validation study to date, demonstrating the exceptional accuracy, reliability, and relevance of its innovative tools. This rigorous research further solidifies Aptive Index as a trusted partner for CEOs, business leaders, and HR professionals aiming to transform their hiring and team-building strategies.
The comprehensive study involved over 400 participants and integrated data from thousands of prior assessments, solidifying Aptive Index’s position as a leader in psychometric evaluation. Results demonstrated that Aptive Index consistently outperforms industry benchmarks in measuring personality and work-style attributes essential for successful organizational alignment.
Aptive Index uses seven key behavioral and hardwired work-style traits to help businesses match people with roles where they will thrive. This approach goes beyond traditional methods by looking at how someone’s natural tendencies align with the needs of a job or team. The result is lower turnover, stronger team connections, and more satisfied employees.
The study demonstrated exceptional reliability metrics across all key indicators. The four primary attributes of Influence, Sociability, Consistency, and Precision showed outstanding composite reliability scores ranging from 0.831 to 0.889, significantly exceeding industry standards. These core measurements were further validated by strong test-retest correlations, with Sociability showing particularly robust stability at 0.922. Factor analysis revealed high construct validity with Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin (KMO) values between 0.781 and 0.892, confirming the assessment's precision in measuring distinct attributes. Collectively, these metrics establish the Aptive Index as one of the most reliable and scientifically validated tools available for talent optimization and strategic hiring decisions.
Further findings revealed the Aptive Index’s impact on reducing employee turnover, a key challenge for businesses worldwide. By aligning candidates with roles suited to their strengths and natural work styles, the assessment directly addresses the costly consequences of turnover, which can range from 30% to 150% of an employee’s annual salary. Aptive Index enables companies to foster more cohesive teams and improve retention rates by ensuring the right fit for every role.
Aptive Index also excels in promoting diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) through its assessments. Rigorous analysis confirmed that the platform is free from demographic bias, supporting fair and inclusive hiring practices. This feature empowers organizations to build diverse teams while maintaining the highest standards of accuracy and integrity.
“Our mission at Aptive Index is to help organizations make smarter, data-driven decisions that empower individuals and teams,” said Jason P. Carroll, Founder and CEO of Aptive Index. “This validation study demonstrates not only the precision of our platform but also the tangible benefits it brings to the workplace, from reducing turnover to promoting inclusivity.”
Click here to download the full validation documentation. [Aptive Index Comprehensive Validation Report.pdf]
In the landscape of professional assessments, personality tests have dominated for decades. However, a different type of assessment—the conative test—offers unique insights that traditional personality assessments can't capture. These tests measure not who we are (personality) or what we know (cognitive), but how we naturally take action when faced with problems to solve.
Typing "conative" into your device will cause it to get red squiggly-lined, and maybe even autocorrected to "cognitive." But trust us, it’s a real word.
What is Conation and What Do Conative Tests Measure?
Conation comes from the Latin word "conatus," meaning "effort" or "striving." It represents our innate drive to act and solve problems—the natural, hardwired tendencies that influence how we approach tasks, make decisions, and interact with our environment.
While personality tests measure adaptable behaviors and preferences shaped by experience, conative tests measure more stable, innate drives that have typically been consistent since our teenage years. These drives represent how we are hardwired to work when free from external pressures.
Conative tests measure attributes such as:
- Natural pace and approach to tasks
- Innate tendencies toward structure versus flexibility
- Drive for precision and detail
- Motivation to influence outcomes or lead
- Need for social interaction versus independent work
- Adaptability to change versus preference for consistency
Benefits of Measuring Conative Traits
Understanding conative traits offers several advantages over solely relying on personality assessments:
1. Greater Stability Over Time
Conative traits tend to remain more consistent throughout adulthood, while personality can shift significantly based on environment, roles, and experiences. This stability makes conative assessments particularly valuable for long-term career planning and development.
2. Prediction of Natural Performance
Conative assessments help predict how someone will naturally perform in various environments. When someone's conative drives align with their role requirements, they often experience:
- Reduced stress and burnout
- Higher job satisfaction
- Better performance with less effort
- Longer tenure in roles
3. Insight Into Team Dynamics
Understanding the conative drives of team members reveals natural strengths and potential friction points, allowing leaders to:
- Optimize task allocation based on innate strengths
- Improve communication by acknowledging different working styles
- Create more balanced teams with complementary drives
- Reduce unnecessary conflict stemming from different approaches
Popular Conative Assessments in the Market
Kolbe A™ Index
One of the pioneers in conative assessment, the Kolbe A™ Index measures four "Action Modes":
- Fact Finder: How we gather and share information
- Follow Thru: How we organize and arrange
- Quick Start: How we deal with risk and uncertainty
- Implementor: How we handle space and tangibles
The Kolbe uses a 1-10 scale for each mode and focuses exclusively on these conative elements without mixing in personality factors.
Predictive Index
While Predictive Index doesn't specifically label itself a conative assessment, it measures what they call "drives" and needs through a two-list methodology. These drives—Dominance, Extraversion, Patience, and Formality—share similarities with conative factors, though they represent a blend of motivational and behavioral elements rather than pure conative traits.
Aptive Index: A Hybrid Approach to Assessment
Aptive Index represents a next-generation approach that combines elements of both conative and adaptive measurement, designed specifically for today's workplace challenges. The name itself—a blend of "adaptable" and "conative"—reflects this hybrid nature, measuring both hardwired drives and how these express themselves in workplace contexts.
Scientific Foundation
Aptive Index measures eight key attributes that research shows directly impact job performance and satisfaction:
Primary Attributes (ISCP)
- Influence: Drive to impact people, events, and outcomes
- Sociability: Drive for and energy gained from social interaction
- Consistency: Drive for stability, routine, and methodical approaches
- Precision: Drive for accuracy, adherence to rules, and attention to detail
Standalone Attributes
- Emotional Resonance: Ability to deeply connect with emotions
- Prosocial: Drive to support others and contribute to collective wellbeing
- Intensity: Natural pace and sense of urgency when approaching tasks
- Abstraction: Capacity for abstract thought and innovative problem-solving
The inclusion of Intensity as a distinct attribute is particularly valuable, as it measures a person's natural pace and sense of urgency independent from their preference for structure (Consistency) or detail (Precision). This distinction helps explain why some individuals can be simultaneously methodical yet quick-moving, or flexible yet deliberate in their pace.
User Experience Advantages
Designed for practical application in modern organizations, Aptive Index offers:
- Mobile-first platform design for easy access
- 8-minute average completion time versus 60+ minutes for many competitors
- Clear, actionable insights without requiring extensive interpretation
- Modern user interface following contemporary UX principles
Practical Implementation
Rather than purely theoretical insights, Aptive Index provides practical applications for:
- Hiring and selection decisions
- Team composition analysis
- Leadership development
- Conflict resolution
- Communication optimization
The Reality of Conative Assessments: Transparency Matters
While conative tests provide valuable insights, it's important to understand their limitations and proper context:
Stability vs. Rigidity
Conative traits are relatively stable but not completely static. They can shift subtly over time or in response to significant life events. The key distinction is that these shifts are typically:
- Gradual rather than sudden
- Limited in magnitude
- Often temporary during extreme circumstances
For example, someone might show slightly different conative patterns during major life transitions or periods of high stress, but their core tendencies generally remain recognizable.
Accuracy Trade-Offs
Shorter, more accessible assessments like Aptive Index prioritize practical usability and adoption. This creates inevitable trade-offs:
- Depth vs. Accessibility: More comprehensive assessments may provide deeper insights but require significantly more time and expertise to administer and interpret.
- Specificity vs. Applicability: Highly detailed assessments might capture nuanced variations but can become impractical for organizational use.
- Theoretical Purity vs. Practical Value: Some assessments maintain strict theoretical boundaries between conative, cognitive, and affective domains, while others like Aptive Index intentionally incorporate elements that have proven practical value for workplace applications.
Complementary, Not Comprehensive
Conative assessments should be viewed as one valuable tool in a broader toolkit for understanding human potential and performance, not as a complete solution. They work best when combined with:
- Skill and experience evaluation
- Cultural fit assessment
- Interviews and reference checks
- Performance data
Conclusion: The Future of Conative Assessment
As work environments become increasingly complex and dynamic, understanding conative drives becomes even more valuable. Modern assessments like Aptive Index reflect this evolution, combining scientific rigor with practical usability.
The most effective organizations recognize that conative assessment isn't about fitting people into rigid categories but about creating environments where everyone can contribute through their natural strengths while developing strategies to address areas of potential challenge.
By understanding the stable yet nuanced nature of conative drives, organizations can build more effective teams, reduce unnecessary friction, and create the conditions for both individual fulfillment and collective success.
Looking to explore how conative assessment could benefit your organization? Learn more about Aptive Index's modern, mobile-friendly approach to measuring innate drives and optimizing team performance at aptiveindex.com.
Have you ever felt like everything in your life burned to ashes, forcing you to rebuild from nothing? That's exactly where I found myself several years ago—staring at the tattoo of a phoenix spreading across my chest, a permanent reminder of my personal cycle of destruction and rebirth.
But in that particular season of rebuilding, something profound happened. I discovered that the most powerful transformation doesn't come from changing your circumstances; it comes from changing how you understand yourself.
The Self-Awareness Delusion
Here's a startling truth: 90% of people believe they're self-aware, but only 10-15% actually are.
This massive gap isn't just interesting—it's dangerous, especially for leaders. When you lack true self-awareness, you're essentially navigating your life and career with a broken compass, convinced you're heading north while actually moving south.
True self-awareness isn't what most people think it is. It's not just acknowledging your strengths and weaknesses or recognizing when you're stressed. It's a much deeper, more nuanced understanding that operates on three distinct levels.
The Phoenix Framework: Three Levels of Self-Awareness
After years of working with executives and building businesses, I've developed what I call the Phoenix Framework—a three-level approach to achieving genuine self-awareness that can transform both your leadership and your life.
Level 1: Data - Knowing Your Behaviors
Most people stop here, mistaking it for complete self-awareness. This level involves recognizing your behavioral patterns:
- How you typically react in meetings
- Your communication style
- Your decision-making approach
- Your habits under pressure
This knowledge is valuable but limited. It tells you what you do, but not why it matters or what drives it.
Think of a leader who recognizes they tend to dominate conversations. They might work on talking less, but without deeper understanding, they'll likely replace one surface behavior with another without addressing the underlying dynamics.
Level 2: Impact - Recognizing Your Effect
This is where self-awareness begins to have real power. Understanding the ripple effects of your behaviors changes everything.
At this level, you recognize:
- How your actions affect others
- The unintended consequences of your communication style
- The organizational impacts of your leadership approach
- The emotional responses you trigger in different situations
When that same leader who dominates conversations understands that their behavior makes team members feel undervalued and less likely to share critical information, they're motivated to change in a way that simple behavioral awareness never could achieve.
Impact awareness transforms leadership because it connects behaviors to consequences. It's the difference between knowing you interrupt people and understanding that your interruptions are silencing the voices you most need to hear.
Level 3: Drives - Uncovering Your Core Motivations
This is the deepest and most transformative level of self-awareness. Here, you understand the innate drives and motivations that fuel your behaviors:
- What are your fundamental needs?
- What gives you energy versus what drains you?
- What hardwired tendencies shape your natural approach?
- What are you unconsciously seeking or avoiding?
Our dominating leader might discover they have a high drive for influence—a natural need to shape outcomes and direct conversations. This insight is powerful because it reveals that their need isn't wrong; it's just being expressed in a counterproductive way.
With an awareness of their drive, they can find healthier ways to satisfy that influence need—perhaps by focusing on asking powerful questions or by channeling their energy into strategic planning sessions where directive input is more valuable.
Why All Three Levels Matter
Each level of the Phoenix Framework builds on the previous one, creating a comprehensive understanding that transforms how you lead and live:
Data alone leads to surface-level behavioral tweaks that rarely stick.
Data + Impact creates meaningful motivation for change but may lead to suppressing natural drives rather than channeling them effectively.
Data + Impact + Drives allows for authentic transformation by helping you satisfy your core needs in ways that create positive rather than negative impact.
Rising From Your Own Ashes
The phoenix doesn't just rebuild itself identically after burning—it emerges as something new and more powerful. True self-awareness works the same way.
When you understand not just your behaviors but their impact and the drives behind them, you don't simply become a "better version" of yourself. You transform into something fundamentally more effective and authentic.
For me, that tattoo across my chest became more than just a symbol of surviving difficult times. It became a daily reminder of the continuous cycle of self-discovery and reinvention that powers genuine growth.
The most profound leadership tool isn't found in business books or management theories. It's found in the mirror—but only when you know how to look beyond the surface to see the complete picture of who you are, how you affect others, and what truly drives you forward.
Are you ready to rise from the ashes of self-unawareness?